Open Thread Tuesdays: User or Collector?

On other blogs that I’ve been part of, we’ve occasionally set aside a post every once in a while for discussion. I would love to get a dialog going between all of the online pencil bloggers, users, and collectors, because I think we can all benefit from sharing advice, tips, specific interests, etc.

So here goes: I’ll post a topic to get us started, and feel free to keep us on my topic, or start your own. No real guidelines, just keep it clean (as I know you will).

Larry Derrenberger, of Elkhart, Ind. (my home state!). This image was part of an article about the annual American Pencil Collectors Society convention at Minnesota State University in 2006. Full article and photo credit here.

TOPIC: My interest in pencils started with using and reviewing pencils, new ones that were available in the consumer market. I still love them. However, I also delight in finding old, vintage pencils and those with advertising or slogans on the barrel. There seems to often be a schism between pencil “users”, and pencil “collectors“. Where do you find yourself, or are you a citizen of both worlds like me? Why?

2 thoughts on “Open Thread Tuesdays: User or Collector?

  1. I understand the collectors’ obsession but I can’t be a collector – I’m not so consistent and methodical. I buy pencils on a whim – to use them or just to look at them or because they mean something real or imaginary to me.

  2. Palimpsest,

    Understandable. I agree with you — what good is a collection if you can’t interact with it and see what it is you have? Of course, my “collecting” pencils mostly include souvenir an advertising pencils, which most likely performs fairly average or poorly, depending on the quality of the pencil stock they used. The fine quality pencils I can’t keep away from trying out, so that’s why they’re usually in my “use” stock.

    Where those two collide with me, and what causes me the most conflict, is what I should do with the vintage “fine-quality” pencils I have, like an OLD Eberhard-Faber Microtomic, or an ancient Venus Velvet that I want to see how it works after all these years. Usually, I break down and write a couple sentences with the vintage pencils I get that are already sharpened, but I haven’t been able to bring myself to use an unsharpened pencil yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s