A Palomino Blackwing Pearl review

I’ve been a bad pencil blogger, folks.

Pencils.com introduced the Blackwing Pearl back in early May — more than two months ago. I posted two different preview articles about them then, but have been silent since.

It’s not through lack of interest. I’ve used the Pearl almost exclusively since then, switching away to a different Blackwing or a Golden Bear just to compare and contrast.

Box of Palomino Pearl pencils by Pencils.com

I’ve gone through three pencils, and I finally think I’m ready for a review.


I have to admit, the Blackwing Pearl is gorgeous.

The owner of a local winery (and a client of my employer) took notice of this pencil and bought several dozen to use in the wine tasting room. It compliments the minimalist style of the facility, and a good friend of mine who works there tells me they are running out — patrons keep taking them!

Two-EEs Winery bought a bunch of these pencils because of their style.

Two-EEs Winery bought a bunch of these pencils because of their style.

Visually, this is a logical follow up to the PB Classic and the PB 602 — the pearlescent lustre (that’s right, I spelled that like a British person) looks really nice next to the grey sharkskin of a 602, which sets off the matte black of the original PB.

The Palomino Blackwing family

You can tell which of the Blackwings is most loved in my arsenal.

I have a little bit of an OCD eye twitch that goes off when I think about how, from darkest to lightest, the color of the barrel is:

  • PB Classic
  • PB 602
  • PB Pearl

Yet, from darkest to lightest, the marking of the graphite is:

  • PB Classic
  • PB Pearl
  • PB 602

One thing I got wrong in my (otherwise amazing) mockup of the Pearl was the words stamped on the side. Rather than gold foil, it’s stamped with black, which provides a strong contrast to the barrel paint. And, it matches the black eraser, which brings a little continuity. It’s the little things; I love that.

The barrel of the Palomino Blackwing Pearl

The element that feels out of place, though, is the brass ferrule. I think a steel one would look better, and make the barrel look more pearly. The ferrule here isn’t too gold, though — it’s more subtle, so it still looks really, really good.


The Palomino Blackwing Pearl writing test against its siblings.

Pencils.com refers to the Pearl as “balanced and smooth”, as a medium ground between the soft PB Classic, which is great for sketching, and the harder PB 602, which is best for writing.

I’ll definitely agree with this assessment. It feels like a great balance between the two previous pencils. In fact, I’d say that it tends to run almost as dark as the Classic, but holds a point much longer, close to the 602.

The eraser does leave dust, but it erases pretty clearly.

The eraser is the same as what comes with the 602 — a black, pumice-like “dust free” eraser. It works great (though it’s not dust free), and it looks beautiful; in high-contrast glory with the white barrel.


I’m a big fan. For my purposes, it’s miles ahead of the PB Classic.

My go-to Blackwing of choice is still the 602, however. I’m more than happy to sacrifice a bit of darkness in my markings to keep the tip as sharp as possible for as long as possible. But then again, I use pencils almost exclusively to write. Coworkers who scribble notes as well as sketch have remarked that they love this; it truly is a great balance between the other two.

The Palomino Blackwing Pearl can be purchased from Pencils.com for $19.95 per dozen, or if you’re feeling ambitious, you can get a gross (that’s 144 pencils) for $163.98.


There’s a few other pencil and scribomechanica bloggers who were on top of reviews. Check out their posts:

9 thoughts on “A Palomino Blackwing Pearl review

  1. Great review, and great photos to boot! This pencil got the least hype and is probably the best designed and executed version, with the best core, too. 🙂

    Say, hey, what’s that you’re sharpening that beauty with? 🙂

  2. Pingback: Monday Links … | The Pretense of Knowledge

  3. Pingback: Link Love: The Two Weeks Late Edition | The Well-Appointed Desk

  4. Pingback: A Palomino Blackwing Pearl review

  5. I ordered a 12-pack of the 602’s about a year ago, and I just sharpened the last of ’em. I primarily use them for drawing, and even have one pictured in the banner of my blog.

    Something about the white design made me think it’d be lighter than the 602, but I dig that it’s supposed to be even darker. I plan on ordering another box of 602’s, but I might just try a box of Pearls too. I don’t like the “Original Blackwing” design at all. The white eraser has that modern look to it and the matte finish makes it look cheap to me, you know?

    And you’re right about the gold on the Pearl. It should be chromed, I agree. And why not? It’s not like it’s a reincarnation of the original E.F pencils like the 602 (especially the new Chuck Jones release, with the pink erasers). I think they should do it.

  6. Pingback: A review of the Palomino Blackwing 725: the inaugural Volumes edition | Woodclinched

  7. Pingback: Pencil Review: Palomino Blackwing Pearl – Pens and Junk

  8. This review tipped the scales. I’m buying the Pearl for NaNoWriMo. I will probably use Sakura Sumo Grip erasers and leave the beautiful Blackwing erasers untouched. Thanks for the information!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s